Sunday, 11 August 2013

The moral dilemna of surveillance



Former NSA employee Edward Snowden's disclosure of the mass-surveillance programs perpetrated by the US government (with assistance from Australia, New Zealand, the UK and France) earlier this year, as well as the media circus that has surrounded it, raises a number of ethical and social questions regarding surveillance. Is the supposed increase in national security worth the price of individual privacy? Should those with nothing to hide be worried about this invasion of privacy? Is mass surveillance in the best interests of the people, or is it an abuse of power? Do the systems in place hold the potential for malevolent misuse in the future?

As expected, many comparisons have already been made to George Orwell's classic novel Nineteen-Eighty Four, a cautionary (and some say prophetic) tale of surveillance society taken to a dystopian extreme. The idea of being unable to escape the gaze of authority, and never knowing whether or not you are being watched is a terrifying idea to the vast majority of people, and one I encountered under a different context last semester when learning about Michael Foucault's writings on the panopticon. The panopticon is a kind of prison in which the guards can see into every single cell from a central guard tower, instilling the inmates with the feeling of being watched constantly, as they have no way of knowing if the guards are looking at any given moment. This concept serves as a perfect metaphor for the paranoia the PRISM program drives. Caluya (2010, p. 622-623) summarizes Foucault's writings on the panopticon, describing it as a punishment of the soul, and representative of a broader change in the social order. Is the US government, therefore, exacting a form of psychological punishment upon its citizens? Further drawing on Foucault's ideas, PRISM can be seen as exerting its power through its penetrating gaze. 

While many would argue that the gathering of phone records and the monitoring of internet searches does not constitute the Orwellian destruction of individual rights it is often portrayed as, it represents an alarming shift in that direction. In a recent example, an American family was visited by six heavily armed and armoured men from a terrorism task-force (Bump, 2013). The reason? Within a short space of time, the husband had Googled 'backpacks' and the wife had Googled 'pressure cooker bombs'. Not only is this a tacit admission that the activities of citizens within their own homes are being closely monitored, but it's telling of the paranoia that pervades the United States. While the full implications of this discovery remain to be seen, it is clear that this is a pivotal time in the history of surveillance and politics.

References


Caluya, G 2010, ‘The post-panoptic society? Reassessing Foucault in surveillance studies’, Social Identities, vol. 16, no. 5, pp. 621 - 63.

Bump, P 2013, 'Update: Now We Know Why Googling 'Pressure Cookers' Gets a Visit from Cops', The Atlantic Wire, 1 August, retrieved 4 August 2013, <http://www.theatlanticwire.com/national/2013/08/government-knocking-doors-because-google-searches/67864/>