Thursday, 4 October 2012

Does organised religion have a place in a global society?



In recent decades, the rapid trend towards globalisation in developed countries has been accompanied by a similarly rapid rise in the number of people in these countries who identify themselves as atheists, non-believers, agnostics or at the very least believers with no affiliation with any organised religion. The populations of many European nations, including (and most notably) Sweden, Denmark, Norway, The Czech Republic and Finland, are estimated to be over 50% atheist or agnostic, according to a 2005 study by Phil Zuckerman (Evolution Space 2007). Asian countries such as Japan and South Korea also ranked highly in this study, although it is difficult to compare them due to the disparity between the major theistic religions and non-theistic Asian religions such as Shinto and Buddhism. Interestingly, these countries are also notable for being wealthy, advanced, educated and relatively low in crime, and for being major global forces culturally, economically and politically. This trend is nothing new, however: the major monotheistic religions were all born in poor, illiterate, desperate parts of the Middle East, as opposed to, say, China or ancient Rome and Greece, where philosophy and more modern legal systems were already taking over from superstition and fear of divine punishment. Much of the original purpose of religion no longer has any relevance to the modern world, so what use is it today? What role, if any, does it play for the benefit of humanity in this increasingly globalised and connected world? 

Globalisation can be defined, in its simplest and most basic form, as the compression of time and space (Nederveen Pieterse 2004, pp. 8). Driven by new transport and communication technologies, as well as immigration, education and improving international relations, it is a force that brings cultures, peoples, products and ideas closer together, both literally and figuratively. This can, in some cases, be a destructive force. For example, linguists estimate that approximately half of the some 6,500 languages worldwide are in danger of, or on the brink of, extinction as a result of the more widely-spoken languages (particularly English) taking over (Dastgoshadeh & Jalilzadeh, 2011 pp. 661). Is religion falling to a similar fate? The death of religion in an increasingly modern and globalised world is something that has been discussed at length, perhaps most famously in the secularisation thesis. Peter Berger (2001, pp. 443), a major and early proponent of the thesis, defines secularisation as "a process in which in which religion diminishes in importance both in society and in the consciousness of individuals." While early estimates of when religion would become a nonissue have since been proven false, simply by way of the estimated dates passing by without much progress in the theory, the fact that these estimates carry any credibility to begin with points to a growing trend. Globalisation and the vehicles that drive it, while not often seen as causes of secularisation, hold at least some of the blame. Where centuries (or even decades) ago, the vast majority of the world would have no choice but to accept the religious teachings of wherever they lived in lieu of any opposing ideas and teachings from other parts of the world entering their 'bubble', anyone with internet access can access a vast amount of knowledge and debate on the topic. The internet allows people to be exposed to a multitude of opposing ideas and as a result make up their own minds. The large amount of anti-religious material on the internet, much of it dismantling religious beliefs through logic and reason (or simply making fun of them), has the potential to be highly influential to the online generation. On a smaller scale, widespread immigration and travel means that an individual easily can go out and meet people of different beliefs, often breaking down an misconceptions they might have had about these people.

So religion is on the decline, however slowly, and this begs the question: is religion needed in the modern world, by individuals or society as a whole? The answer to this question depends on which parts of the world we look at. In the many of the more disadvantaged parts of the world, religion still plays a central role in both private and public life. In places where this is the case, it is often because the religion still fulfills the same purposes it has for centuries: it provides an absolute system of morality to help police the populace, it provides meaning and hope in the lives of those who would otherwise find little of either, and it can support national and political interests (Hollinger, Haller & Valle-Hollinger 2007, pp. 136-137). The thesis put forward by Hollinger, Haller & Valle-Hollinger (2007, pp. 135) is as follows:

The level of religious participation and the strength of religious belief in a given society is
a function of the ability of national religious institutions to meet the spiritual and
emotional needs of citizens. Assuming a change in the levels and scope of religious
needs, specific historical forms of religion or religious institutions will lose in importance
to be supplemented or replaced by substantially new forms of non-institutional, private,
and ‘invisible’ forms of religion or religion-equivalents.

This sums up the essence of why religion is approaching obsolescence in the more modern parts of the world; as quality of life improves, more people receive better educations and opportunities to find fulfilment in life increase, the need for faith diminishes. Not only are the beneficial aspects of organised religion losing their worth, but in some cases it actually holds modernisation and development back. For example, the rapid change in public opinion on gay marriage in western countries most likely would have lead to changes in legislation, where it not for the large amounts of purely religion-based opposition among politicians and lawmakers. Another example is the anti-contraception teachings of the Catholic Church, which have been heavily criticised as archaic and irresponsible, and even linked to the spread of the AIDS virus in Africa. Both of these examples demonstrate that religion is not only not needed in the modern world, but may not even have a deserving place in it.

Despite failing to estimate the timeframe in which religion would die out, proponents of the secularisation thesis may eventually see their predicted future of a secular world come true. The trend is definitely there: it is simply a matter of 'when' for much of Europe, Asia and possibly even Australia and North America. As for the rest of the world, it remains to be seen. However, regardless of whether or not the modern world ever becomes truly secular, it is clear that organised religion at the very least is not needed, and at its worst has no relevant place in a educated, progressive, free and equal society.

References

Dastgoshadeh, A & Jalilzadeh, K 2011, 'Language loss, Identity, and English as an International Language', European Journal of Science, vol. 21, issue 4, retrieved 7 September 2012, <http://ehis.ebscohost.com/ehost/detail?sid=69afb27b-6b10-4562-bd29-64ab87097513%40sessionmgr104&vid=3&hid=3&bdata=JnNpdGU9ZWhvc3QtbGl2ZQ%3d%3d#db=a9h&AN=67545893>.

Evolution Space 2007, 'Worldwide Atheism Trend and Pattern – A Summary', retrieved 30 September 2012, <http://evolutionspace.wordpress.com/2007/05/03/worldwide-atheism-trend-and-pattern-a-summary>.

Nederveen Pieterse, J 2004, ‘Globalization: consensus and controversies’, Globalization and culture: global mélange, Rowan & Littlefield, Lanham, Md., pp. 7–21.

Berger, P 2001, 'Religion and Globalization at the Turn of the Millennium', Sociology of Religion, vol. 62, no. 4, pp. 443-454, retrieved 3 October 2012, <http://www.jstor.org/discover/10.2307/3712435?uid=3737536&uid=2&uid=4&sid=21101102031053>.

Hollinger, F, Haller, M & Valle-Hollinger, A 2007, 'Christian religion, society and the state in the modern world', Innovation, vol. 20, no. 2, pp. 133-154.